Racism,
Ableism, Heterosexism
|
24
- Hour Crisis Line: (613)
562-2333
This
site is not intended to provide counselling, legal, medical or
emotional support. If you require support or more information
on the options available to you, please contact the 24 hour crisis
line.
Sexism,
Racism, Ableism, Heterosexism, Classism:
Making the Links with Sexual Violence
Sexual assault experiences are embedded within the personal, as
well as the social and historical context within which we all
live. To acknowledge the diversity and complexity of female experience,
violence against women has to be considered in relation to an
entire structure of domination of which patriarchy is but one
part. Sexism, as it intersects with racism, classism, homophobia
and able-ism, and a range of other experiences will affect women's
responses to the trauma of sexual violence.
Forms
of oppression are designed to control, confine and exploit one
group of people for the benefit of another group of people. There
are many strategies used to oppress people. For example, sexism
is about objectifying women and girls. When a woman or girl is
objectified (viewed as an object not as a human being)
it becomes acceptable to treat her in any way.
This is
similar to how racism works. Racism allows white people to view
people of colour as inhuman, as objects that can be treated in
any way. Language, too, is used to assert power over people. Name
calling, for example, is part of the pattern of violence. Calling
people living in poverty "lazy welfare bums" makes them less deserving
of basic economic and social rights. Calling women whores denies
women's rights to claim their sexual power and the power to control
our bodies. Another strategy of oppression is to trick someone
into believing that she has more value by her association with
the abuser/oppressor than she could have in her own self. For
example, society often sees the partner as a martyr or hero for
being in a relationship with a woman who has a disability, ie,
"people wonder why I married you." Another strategy is to threaten
survival and break the person's will a tactic that underpinned
slavery and is part of the continuing colonization of indigenous
people today.
Some other
examples include:
-
Blaming
and punishing poor people for their own poverty and for society's
social and economic problems reinforces the attitude that it
is all right to treat people living in poverty as less than
human. It suggests that the rights of poor people are less important
than the rights of those who have money. Poor women's rights
have always been vulnerable. They are now at risk even more
with the dismantling of the welfare state. Women living in poverty
do not have enough to afford adequate housing, food and clothing.
They are at greater risk for homelessness, and women continue
to stay in abusive relationships because they do not receive
sufficient social assistance to make it a viable option to leave
the relationship;
-
Some
women with disabilities are dependent on their partner's support,
a circumstance abusers can use to reinforce their control. The
abusive partner, for example, might perpetuate the myth that
a woman with a disability is child-like by encouraging others
to speak to him rather than to her, or never allowing her personal
time with anyone, including professionals (such as physicians).
His control tactics may be disguised as caring support. A woman
may feel that she has no other options even if it means being
abused.
-
Recognize
the ways in which we are implicated in perpetuating (forms of)
oppression in other women's lives, through our race, class,
sexual orientation, etc.;
-
Break
the invisibility of privilege. Keep track of your own privilege.
Analyze what you gain from racism, homophobia, able-ism, and
what you lose from such systems of domination;
Definitions
Classism:
A system of institutional practices and individual actions that
allow a few people to control most of the wealth and power in society
to the disadvantage of the majority of people.
Heterosexism:
Institutionalized policies and individual actions that promote
a heterosexual lifestyle above all others. It assumes that a heterosexual
pattern of loving is superior over all other patterns of loving
and that a woman's life will be defined in relation to a man.
Racism:
Is to people of colour what sexism is to women. It is the assumption
that one race is superior to another. It also assumes that the abilities
of an individual are determined by their race.
Sexism:
An integral part of the social structure under which we live that
exploits women and confers privileges to men over women.
Ableism:
Institutionalized practices and individual actions and beliefs
that posit the able-body as the norm. It works to promote negative
images of disAbled women, such as the myth that it is not possible
for someone with a disability to have a positive and equal relationship.
Back
to top
Access
& Equity at the ORCC
The Ottawa Rape Crisis
Centre has been committed to providing inclusive and accessible
services throughout our existence. In meeting the challenges of
making our services accessible to all women, we have achieved important
successes in recent years. These include:
- Holding a two-day
workshop in November 1999 entitled: "Training for Trainers in
a Multicultural context." This workshop succeeded in facilitating
an exchange of information, skills, and resources relating to
sexual assault services for women of diverse ethnoracial/cultural
communities;
- Conducting a preliminary
needs assessment on services for immigrant and refugee women who
have experienced rape in war;
- Developing a valuable
partnership with the Aboriginal Women's Support Centre, enabling
us to successfully provide services to Aboriginal women;
- Reviewing personnel
and operational policies and procedures (i.e. the way the ORCC
advertises, recruits and screens potential job candidates) thereby
significantly increasing ethnoracial/cultural representation of
the ORCC staff;
- Completing renovations
to make the first floor of the building accessible to women with
physical disabilities;
- Providing support
and counselling to sex trade workers who have experienced sexual
violence;
- Active outreach to
community organizations who service women with disabilities.
Back
to top
An
Anti-Racist Feminist Approach
In the past few
years we have acknowledged that despite these important steps and
good intentions, the ORCC was still not representative of the community
we serve. With this recognition, we've renewed our commitment to
becoming accessible and equitable. Currently, we are actively taking
measures to identify and challenge the structural elements of the
organization that contribute to the reproduction of inequalities
and the marginalization of various groups of women.As such, we have
embarked on a process of transformative change through an anti-racist
feminist framework.
Why Focus on Anti-Racist
Feminism?
While the ORCC continues its commitment to becoming accessible to
all women who are marginalized on the basis of sexuality, dis-Ability,
socio-economic status, etc., we believe working through an anti-racist
feminist approach will better enable us to confront all forms of
oppression. This focus enables us to identify and challenge racism
as a more integrated approach to achieving access and equity.
Immigrant, refugee, and
women of colour in our community are at high risk of violence (Statistics
Canada, 1995) because of the multiple and overlapping ways sexism,
racism, and socio-economic factors impact our lives. Immigrant,
refugee and women of colour face difficulties accessing information
and support services to help them heal from violence. Many service
providers working with immigrant, refugee and women of colour have
told us that they have had little or no training in offering culturally
sensitive support and services in issues related to sexual violence
.This is further compounded by the lack of resources available to
agencies servicing members of marginalized communities. All these
factors have flagged the need for the ORCC to provide culturally
sensitive and appropriate support to refugee, immigrant and women
of colour who have experienced sexual violence.
Many obstacles prevent
women from disclosing experiences of sexual violence and getting
the support we need and deserve. Obstacles such as shame, guilt,
and fear of retaliation prevent many women from disclosing incidents
of sexual abuse. For immigrant and/or visible minority women there
are additional race-specific barriers. For example, historical racialized
gender stereotypes play a role in constructing black women as promiscuous
and always sexually available. Unfortunately such stereotypes impact
the credibility of black women as rape survivors. Furthermore, many
women fear acknowledging incidents of sexual abuse that occur within
our communities. This is in part because such disclosures may reinforce
societal myths of our communities as prone to violent behavior.
The need to protect our communities from racist attacks may keep
us quiet about sexual abuse (White, 1999).
Some basic principles
to implementing an anti-racist, feminist approach will include:
- Ongoing questioning
of white power and privilege;
- Creating spaces for
everyone, but particularly for marginal voices to be heard;
- Dealing with questions
of representation, through the active recruitment, retention and
promotion of women of colour as volunteers, board members and
staff. The mere representation of a range of ethnoracial differences
at all levels of decision making helps the redistribution of power.
"It
is not that individuals in the designated groups are inherently
unable to achieve equality on their own, it is that the obstacles
in their way are so formidable and self-perpetuating that they
can not be overcome without intervention. It is both intolerable
and insensitive if we simply wait and hope that the barriers
will disappear with time. Equality in employment will not happen
unless we make it happen."
Royal
Commission on Equality in Employment
Some Challenges That
Lay Ahead:
To effectively achieve
the goal of becoming an anti-racist organization, we have made the
commitment to openly and honestly look at the challenges we have
faced and are currently facing in becoming inclusive. It is also
important to emphasize that we are at the very early stages of this
process and only a few, initial steps have been taken. A commitment
to implementing such change involves transforming the taken for
granted belief systems and structures that perpetuate inequities.
As such, we recognize that this process will not be easy.
We have identified the
following initial steps to help us achieve our goal of becoming
anti-racist:
- Undertake a comprehensive
review of ORCC's policies, practices and materials;
- Actively work to create
a climate that promotes respect for, and acceptance of, the diversity
of women in the organization;
- Through discussion
and dialogue, examine and uncover the belief systems underpinning
advocacy work and social work and the way we provide these services;
- A move away from tokenist
attempts of "accepting" and "bringing in" women from marginalized
communities to ensuring a sense of ownership and belongingness
for all women at the ORCC;
- Allocate funds to
a part-time "Anti-Racism Coordinator" staff position;
- Increase immigrant
women, women of colour, and refuge women's awareness of the services
of ORCC;
- Develop a peer mentoring
program whereby ORCC staff and service providers working in diverse
racial and cultural communities can establish lasting, professional
relationships that will allow ongoing mutual exchanges of skills,
information and support;
- On-going critical
examination of the way different "isms" work together to oppress
disenfranchised people.
"Access,
representation, inclusion, exclusion, equity. All are other
ways of saying race in this country without saying that we live
in a deeply racialised and racist culture which represses the
life possibilities of people of colour. We have to be careful
of the way those words have become bureaucratic glosses for
human suffering. We have to notice how those words deceptively
explain away the vulgar, privileging, power relations that whites
in the country don't want to admit to or give up."
Dionne
Brand from: "Notes for Writing Thru Race" in Bread Out of
Stone .
Back
to top
References
Brand, Dionne. 1995.
Bread Out of Stone: Recollections, Recognition, Dreaming; Sex,
Race, Politics. Toronto: Coach House Press.
Canadian Heritage. 2000.
Racism. Stop It! Hull, QC: Multiculturalism Program.
Dei, George. J. S. 1996.
Anti-Racism Education Theory and Practice. Halifax: Fernwood
Publishing.
Statistics Canada. 1995.
Highlights In Women In Canada: A Statistical Report, Third Edition.
pp. 8 -10. Ottawa, ON: Minister Responsible for Statistics Canada.
White, Janelle. 1999.
Spring Newsletter. San Francisco Women Against Rape's Women
of African Descent Task Group.
Back
to top
Recommended
Reading
Bishop, Anne. 1994. Becoming
an Ally: Breaking the Cycle of Oppression. Halifax: Fernwood
Publishing.
Canadian Council on Social
Development. 2000. Canadian Fact Book on Poverty 2000. Ottawa:
CCSD.
Dua, Enakshi and Angela
Robertson, eds. 1999. Scratching the Surface: Canadian Anti-Racist
Feminist Thought. Toronto: WomenÕs Press.
Enough is Enough:
Aboriginal Women Speak Out.1987. Toronto: Women's Press.
hooks, bell. 1995. Killing
Rage: Ending Racism. New York: Henry Holt & Company.
Jordan, Judith V. 1997.
Women's Growth in Diversity: More Writings from the Stone Centre.
New York: The Guilford Press.
Kivel, Paul. 1996. Uprooting
Racism: How White People Can Work For Racial Justice. New Society
Publishers.
Moraga, Cherrie and Gloria
Anzaldua. 1981. This Bridge Called My Back: Writings by Radical
Women of Color. New York: Kitchen Table: Women of Color Press.
Razack, Sherene. 1998.
Looking White People in the Eye: Gender, Race and Culture in
Courtrooms and Classrooms. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Back
to top
|